Welcome to Panachallenge!
If you are already a member, Click Here to Log In.
  		     
t t rss cal
    Home   ·   Rules   ·   Mugshots   ·   Challenges   ·   Stats   ·   Forums   ·   Help Register    

  #170 Rule of Thirds, Again 		Entry 2 of 26
   
 
Tranquility       ©2016 johncomyn
Panasonic DMC-LX7       2nd place, 193 points
1/100s, f2.1, ISO 100, 70mm, Aperture Priority, Pattern, no flash
 
Post-Processing: PP info will be listed in the comments after voting begins.       Extra Info: None
 
21 comments on this entry
 Log in to
add a comment

aoc46
Apr 19, 2016		     Congratulations - a great shot and excellent example of Rule of Thirds without being heavy-handed about it. Reminds me a lot of another favorite example of great composition using ROT, Ansel Adams' "Young Oaks in Winter" - http://shop.anseladams.com/v/vspfiles/photos/1701817103-2.jpg
Mepo
Apr 19, 2016		     Congrats - makes me want to get out hiking.
mrsawyer
Apr 18, 2016		     Congrats on your finish and your subtle use of thirds.
Lo
Apr 18, 2016		     This is really a stunning shot. Congratulations John
johncomyn
Apr 18, 2016		     Thank you to everyone that commented and voted, really nice place to be part of.
    Comments After End of Challenge    
    Comments During Voting    
Amberbug
Apr 18, 2016		     Nice mood shot, but to mayt trees to isolate a third subject.
johncomyn
Apr 18, 2016		     A.N.Other - Read my comment to rd52 below, I don't think rule of thirds just applies to a single element. It is a compositional tool for arranging elements.
A.N.Other
Apr 18, 2016		     Lovely scene but I'm not really getting 'Rule of Thirds' from it. Very well taken. GL.
Anthony Comyn
Apr 18, 2016		     Stunning is all I need to say... This is perfectly done... My no 1.
johncomyn
Apr 18, 2016		     rd52 - To me, the left group of trees is on one of the 3rds so is the right group. The water line is on a 3rd and you could say the bright white area is on a 3rd. I don't think there was a requirement to demonstrate the rule of thirds, only to use it in your composition.

In a scene like this, there is no clear dominant subject, the entire image is the subject. Still elements need to be well composed, those elements can be composed using the rule of thirds.
Edited on Apr 18, 2016
rd52
Apr 18, 2016		     I really like the photo, great mood, but I don't think that it clearly shows 'thirds'.
jomari
Apr 18, 2016		     A beautiful scene which meets the thirds rule in a sure but subtle way. High in my favourites.
BarbroS
Apr 18, 2016		     Beautifully melancholic mood, intensely present humidity (my hair starts curling!). Composition, focus, contrasts are just perfect in my eyes. Top choice!
ysal
Apr 17, 2016		     It doesn't scream out "1/3" but I do see it and I really like the overall image. So its in my TT.
aoc46
Apr 17, 2016		     Fabulous!
Lo
Apr 16, 2016		     The darker tree captures the eye, and fulfills the rule of thirds theme. The fog adds a beautiful atmosphere.
Old Finn
Apr 16, 2016		     Took some time for me to understand, that the horizontal border of the pool followed the rule of thirds.
babysister
Apr 15, 2016		     Lovely subject and lighting. The mist is perfect. Right on theme.
forkcandles
Apr 15, 2016		     this has a "A"for artwork
this has a timeless look about it and would look great and big on a wall
davemisunas
Apr 15, 2016		     nice image.. good 1st impression and lighting.. focus is hard to judge as the fog makes everything softer.... in my TT
johncomyn
Apr 14, 2016		     Post Processing Information

Used Nik Color Efex Glamour Glow, Curves adjustment and cloned out a post and some other distracting debris in the water. Resize and Sharpen.
Entry Navigation
First       Prev       Entry
2 of 26 		      Next       Last      

Entry
Navigation



First


Prev

Entry
2 of 26

Next

Last
Vote Stats
27 total votes:

1st  (5): |||||
2nd  (7): |||||||
3rd  (1): |
4th  (3): |||
5th  (5): |||||
6th  (2): ||
7th  (1): |
8th  (1): |
9th  (2): ||
10th  (0):  

[Votes]


By johncomyn


Canada
41 Challenge
entries:

#150:  10th
#151:  7th
#152:  13th
#155:  1st
#156:  6th
#158:  13th
#159:  17th
#162:  44th
#163:  2nd
#165:  4th
#171:  7th
#177:  4th
#178:  2nd
#179:  4th
#180:  6th
#181:  1st
#182:  1st
#185:  1st
#187:  1st
#188:  5th
#189:  11th
#190:  4th
#191:  16th
#192:  6th
#193:  4th
#195:  1st
#196:  13th
#197:  6th
#198:  12th
#199:  2nd
#201:  2nd
#203:  2nd
#204:  3rd
#205:  14th
#207:  2nd
#211:  3rd
#212:  3rd
#213:  7th
#215:  8th
#216:  2nd
#221:  7th

Avg rank:
7th



Entry
Navigation



First


Prev

Entry
2 of 26

Next

Last
    Comments? Suggestions? Problems? Click here!       Disclaimer