Welcome to Panachallenge!
If you are already a member, Click Here to Log In.

 
     
t t rss cal
    Home   ·   Rules   ·   Mugshots   ·   Challenges   ·   Stats   ·   Forums   ·   Help Register    

  #236 Furniture
Entry 2 of 20
   
 
Big Screen Chair       ©2020 Jade O.
Panasonic DMC-FZ30       2nd place, 141 points
1/30s, f2.8, ISO 100, 37mm, Normal Program, Pattern, flash
 
Post-Processing: Shot chair, television, window, scene, expanded wall and floor, mounted TV, inserted view, mounted window, inserted view, adjust curves, various clone out and smudge       Extra Info: None
 
22 comments on this entry
Log in to
add a comment

SteveBee
7 days ago
    Honestly, I voted very quickly and paid little attention to the Extra Info. I recall wondering how the image was shot. One possibility I considered was that you took a photo of the outside scene, somehow loaded the resulting image onto the TV screen, and then took a single shot of the scene. To me, that would be a completely legitimate photo, not computer art. So, yes, had I known how you actually created the image, I would have voted differently.

Jade O.
7 days ago
    Oh oh. I just realized extra info. meant that part that is visible during voting. Steve, you are right. This image should be disqualified from the voting tally.

While those commenting seemed to appreciate this was a composite image, there is no way of knowing if all who voted did, and, I assume given Steve's first place vote, and his own views of what constitutes photography, that he didn't and wouldn't have voted for this entry if he did.
Edited on Oct 14, 2020

Jade O.
7 days ago
    I've added this comment after Steve's later comment above this one, but to clarify for Steve and others, there were four images at play here. The first image is of the chair on the floor in front of a blank wall, then to that I added the second image of the TV, the third image was the window, and the fourth image was the scene outside the window that you will find in outtakes.
Edited on Oct 14, 2020

SteveBee
7 days ago
    If I understand your post-processing explanation, you composited multiple separate shots to create the final image. If I understand the rules of the challenge, the use of multiple exposures must be declared in the extra info. You didn't do that.

Although I found the entry to be creative and well done, I think images constructed in this way are computer art rather than photography.

ysal
8 days ago
    Congratulations, very clever and well done.

Lo
8 days ago
    I really enjoyed this shot. Excellent workmanship piecing it all together.

jomari
8 days ago
    Congratulations on 2nd Jade. It's a very creative entry. I must admit I was in the 'horizons should line up camp', but I could see that that would disrupt the continuity with the road. I'll check out your original in outtakes.

Jade O.
9 days ago
    Thank you all for your votes and comments. See outtakes for some alternate views.

    Comments After End of Challenge    
    Comments During Voting    

Mepo
9 days ago
    Well done!

Jade O.
9 days ago
    jomari. I'll put the original outside shot in outtakes.
Edited on Oct 12, 2020

jomari
10 days ago
    You have composited the view into the screen and the window? Very creative.

Jade O.
11 days ago
    aoc I always considered TV part of furniture but certainly the chair isn't as prominent as in my main entry.

kerszkavet I'll post an angle shot in outtakes but I was inspired to try a "flat" minimal depth of field shot. I have a long way to go before I can execute a "Christopher Pratt" but the effect is promising.

Lo I try. If it can't be great photography I figure at least I can try to be original and entertaining.

aoc46
11 days ago
    I think I'm seeing outdoors through the window and the same view on the TV; sorting this out takes much of my attention away from the chair. Well-executed, nonetheless.

kerszkavet
11 days ago
    Nice view!
I think the straight-on chair is a bit lost in this picture - had you considered turning it to an angle?

Lo
11 days ago
    Very creative - the repetition of the scene from the window to the big screen is really well done. I like the balance and simplicity in the composition.

Jade O.
12 days ago
    johncomyn I deliberately sought having the horizons on different levels to draw attention to the different realities but the sweep of the road inadvertently lined up (suggesting it was planned?). You're the second one to comment on that horizon so I suppose if viewers react that it should be lined up then it must be.

Bill Nice to have your comments. I was stuck with the Challenge topic so I felt the title had to reflect it here.

Phil Yes I was showing the irony of how we fixate on technology and miss reality.

ysal As you will see in the Extra Info only the chair floor and wall were in the first shot, everything else was added.

Maike I had the same reaction. I was trying for a bit of Christopher Pratt "flat surrealism" which compresses depth of field to the point that objects appear "stuck on" rather than integrated in the environment.This needs more work to fully obtain the effect but I set out to do this shot about 10:30 p.m. the night before deadline (excepting the outside shot which I got more than a week earlier.)

fc I've always liked those "live wall" effects.

fc

johncomyn
12 days ago
    Clever but your horizons should of met up!

wrosenthal
12 days ago
    Two windows on the world. I like the enigmatic statement and also the comp.The scenery is not bad either!

Phil99
12 days ago
    Weirdly humorous the way someone can sit and watch TV or just look out the window at the same view. Very different and very good.

ysal
12 days ago
    Very clever idea. I can tell that the big screen image is added in by PP since it's near impossible to photograph something on a monitor. Then I assume the window view is also added? It's nicely done and came out great. Couple of things that bother me though, the horizon not lining up between the the two views (the path does), and I'm not sure about the internal lighting. Use of flash seems unnatural and harsh.

Based on the skillful use of PP, I'm guessing who the photographer is, and I admit I like this shot.

Maike13
12 days ago
    This is a beautiful shot so I'm sure it will make my TT, but my first reaction was a bit like "What beautiful pictures. Oh yes, there is a piece of furniture in the shot", Subsequent viewings have moderated that initial reaction somewhat, although I still feel the chair could be a bit more prominent.
Edited on Oct 9, 2020

forkcandles
13 days ago
    big screen are very useful as photo frames
I have seen one with curtains either side with a video camera showing the outside patio
Entry Navigation
First       Prev       Entry
2 of 20
      Next       Last      

Entry
Navigation



First



Prev


Entry
2 of 20


Next


Last

Vote Stats
20 total votes:

1st  (6): ||||||
2nd  (3): |||
3rd  (3): |||
4th  (1): |
5th  (2): ||
6th  (0):  
7th  (1): |
8th  (1): |
9th  (1): |
10th  (2): ||

[Votes]


By Jade O.


Canada

116 Challenge
entries:

#69 63rd
#70 19th
#71 5th
#72 18th
#73 3rd
#74 32nd
#76 11th
#77 10th
#78 15th
#79 4th
#80 7th
#81 19th
#82 12th
#83 5th
#84 7th
#85 8th
#86 10th
#87 14th
#88 6th
#89 6th
#90 7th
#91 8th
#92 8th
#94 11th
#95 13th
#96 13th
#97 6th
#98 5th
#99 13th
#100 10th
#101 1st
#102 4th
#103 18th
#104 1st
#105 4th
#106 17th
#107 18th
#108 6th
#109 10th
#110 10th
#111 9th
#112 7th
#113 5th
#114 4th
#116 6th
#117 28th
#118 13th
#119 1st
#120 9th
#121 2nd
#122 6th
#123 3rd
#124 1st
#125 11th
#126 2nd
#127 4th
#133 1st
#134 2nd
#135 2nd
#136 2nd
#137 15th
#138 3rd
#139 2nd
#140 5th
#141 20th
#142 1st
#143 3rd
#144 10th
#145 4th
#146 4th
#147 33rd
#149 39th
#150 4th
#151 1st
#153 5th
#154 7th
#155 12th
#156 15th
#158 1st
#159 15th
#160 3rd
#161 17th
#163 11th
#165 7th
#166 6th
#167 6th
#168 19th
#169 13th
#170 1st
#171 38th
#172 8th
#173 18th
#174 20th
#180 23rd
#181 11th
#182 10th
#184 28th
#185 31st
#188 22nd
#191 10th
#193 3rd
#195 5th
#196 20th
#197 5th
#200 10th
#202 7th
#210 14th
#254 3rd
#261 17th
#275 20th
#276 3rd
#277 1st
#280 11th
#281 5th
#282 6th
#283 2nd

Avg rank:
10th




Entry
Navigation



First



Prev


Entry
2 of 20


Next


Last
    Comments? Suggestions? Problems? Click here!       Disclaimer