ysal
10 days ago |
 |
Congratulations, a very dramatic image. |
|
Lo
10 days ago |
 |
Congratulations Steve, the detail in this is really excellent, and the star trails are mesmerizing. |
|
Jade O.
10 days ago |
 |
This was my top pick. Wish I could do star trails ....this scene is anything but run of the mill... |
|
 Comments After End of Challenge
 Comments During Voting
|
|
|
Lo
11 days ago |
|
I really like this old mill and the sepia treatment works beautifully. The star trails and moving water add an interesting effect. I would have placed it higher if it were straightened. |
|
kerszkavet
11 days ago |
 |
Fascinating picture, interesting pairing of the time-created water rivulets and the star trails, Great exposure, and choice of sepia gives it a classic feel. |
|
johncomyn
11 days ago |
 |
I can appreciate all the effort that has gone into this image. My only critique would be the leaning mill. Nicely done. |
|
jomari
11 days ago |
 |
Great compositing of the star trails, and a very interesting scene. |
|
Thivi
12 days ago |
 |
This is a fantastic image ! my top pic |
|
Old Finn
12 days ago |
 |
Interesting, historical looking picture. |
|
forkcandles
12 days ago |
 |
interesting result and well done for the sepia finish |
|
babysister
12 days ago |
 |
I sighed and appreciated all the work that has gone into this image. I like the sepia tones. Not sure whether I like the tilt. |
|
Maike13
12 days ago |
 |
I really love this shot although I'm not convinced the star trails really add to it. I think I'd have liked it just as well without them. Impressive technique though. |
|
aoc46
13 days ago |
 |
Great shot of the old mill - the sepia tone reinforces the antiquity. While I'm not a big fan of star trails, they're well done. Might like to darken the bright bits on the center right edge. |
|
Jade O.
13 days ago |
|
From the milky water to the star trails, this is something I have seen many times before - but I couldn't do it. I think the mill is the star (excuse the pun) here and to that degree the star trails both detract attention from the subject and enhance the timelessness of the scene. Not a fan of sepia generally but it works well here. I think I am bothered by the lack of verticals in the building most. That could be corrected by you'd need to layer over the star trails to hold their shape. |
|
Phil99
13 days ago |
 |
Fantastic picture! |
|
RobertLavker
14 days ago |
|
The building and the surrounding water are simply outstanding. The sepia tone is most effective. The star trails are superfluous and somewhat distracting. IMHO- this is a case where less is more. |
|
ysal
14 days ago |
|
I'm not quite sure if the star trails are an addition or a distraction here. The building and the cloudy running water are all stunningly beautiful. I want to focus on those. |
