Welcome to Panachallenge!
If you are already a member,
Click Here to Log In
.
Home
·
Rules
·
Mugshots
·
Challenges
·
Stats
·
Forums
·
Help
Register
#153 Industrial Landscapes
Entry
7
of
33
1st - Zhaark: Industrial Landscape
2nd - SteveBee: Twin Peaks
3rd - aoc46: Sunrise at the Salt Works
4th - A.N.Other: COAL - The past is our future.
5th - Edward: Pipes and Tanks
6th - babysister: Time to wake up
7th - johncomyn: Steam
8th - rd52: generator at ormond
8th - CalicoFrog: Sunset Docks
10th - Jade O.: Winter Harbour
11th - QueenEsther: Towering above us
12th - Andris: Bunkering
13th - mbbin2: Bygone Industry Discovered
14th - kerszkavet: self-concealing chimney
15th - ysal: Towers Against Blue Sky
16th - leanneqld: Industrial Sunset
17th - Sue: The factory at sunset
17th - dk: airborne
19th - kingderry: Quaker on the Otonabee
20th - Old Finn: Old ironworks
21st - cookiejar: Old Warehouse
22nd - aKilter: Colorful Sand Pit
23rd - Paul w: Venice
24th - Voetbal13: blue
25th - Elyod: Industrial Landscape
26th - mrsawyer: 1.4 Billion Dollar New Stadium
27th - Phil99: Steam Clouds
28th - Lo: Abandoned
29th - RobertLavker: Desolation Row
30th - Mepo: Factory Ship
31st - Joanna: They call it Progress
32nd - minzaw: Solar meets Electricity
32nd - forkcandles : the last of its kind
Steam
©2015 johncomyn
NIKON D7000
7th
place,
143
points
1/160s
,
f10
,
ISO 100
,
105mm
,
Aperture Priority
,
Pattern
,
no flash
Post-Processing:
HDR Efex
Cloned out Power lines
Curves
Crop
Lens Correction
Extra Info:
None
20 comments on this entry
Log in to
add a comment
Jade O.
Feb 17, 2015
Nice double!
mrsawyer
Feb 16, 2015
Congrats on your double top ten
SteveBee
Feb 16, 2015
Terrific, John. My #1. Love the style -- very fitting for the theme.
Comments After End of Challenge
Comments During Voting
mrsawyer
Feb 16, 2015
I like this one overall. The bottom edge seems a bit forced as to the crop there. Was there no interesting foreground to include? The HDR may be a bit overdone, but I like it anyway! Good luck in the voting.
A.N.Other
Feb 16, 2015
Great subject and composition but I'm not sure about the processing. Maybe it looked a bit flat without it. I'd love to see the original.
RobertLavker
Feb 16, 2015
Very effective use of HDR to bring dynamism to this image. At first I thought it was sepia toning. You captured the theme very nicely.
aKilter
Feb 16, 2015
Very effective composition and processing. The smoke from the stack really helps, as well. While the processing certainly gives the image impact, it makes the image look too much like an illustration for my tastes.
leanneqld
Feb 15, 2015
Good on theme industrial scene but HDR efex has completely ruined the sky-the pink and white isn't natural. The steam is an added bonus.
Mepo
Feb 15, 2015
I think the HDR is overdone a bit but that's balanced by your skilled composition. Great job; fine image.
forkcandles
Feb 15, 2015
not a fan of HDR however it is not over done here
Sue
Feb 15, 2015
I like the aged feel that this shot has. A fave.
Lo
Feb 15, 2015
Great composition. Perfect for the theme. I really like the use of HDR Efex on this one to give it a stark, minimalist look.
babysister
Feb 14, 2015
The HDR works perfectly with this photo. It is very effective. Well composed and right on theme.
Jade O.
Feb 14, 2015
Fine subject, more foreground?
ysal
Feb 14, 2015
Good use of HDR to bring out the beauty in these industrial structures. Nice composition, great placement (?) of the smoke.
SteveBee
Feb 14, 2015
Theme - 5
Technical - 5 Beautifully stylized, excellent detail,
Composition - 4 Strong composition. My only nit is not showing a little bit of ground at the bottom
Originality - 5
Overall Impression - 5 Compelling image, my favorite
aoc46
Feb 14, 2015
Nice representation of 'Industry in Action'. IMO, a square crop with the steaming stack centered would improve the composition.
Elyod
Feb 14, 2015
I think the HDR could have been toned down a bit, but the smoke is definitely the star in this shot. One of my TT.
Edward
Feb 14, 2015
Interesting HDR version. Nicely composed and has great impact. A top selection.
rd52
Feb 13, 2015
I have just joined Panachallenge after being in FujiMugs for a long time. In FM I don't think HDR ever did all that well, but I have enjoyed it, and I use Photomatix myself. I really enjoy your pics comp and use of HDR. Well done, one of my favs, good luck in the challenge.
Entry Navigation
First
Prev
Entry
7
of
33
Next
Last
Entry
Navigation
First
Prev
Entry
7
of
33
Next
Last
Vote Stats
27
total votes:
1st
(2):
||
2nd
(2):
||
3rd
(6):
||||||
4th
(1):
|
5th
(3):
|||
6th
(1):
|
7th
(2):
||
8th
(4):
||||
9th
(1):
|
10th
(5):
|||||
[
Votes
]
By
johncomyn
Canada
62
Challenge
entries:
#149
:
2nd
#150
:
1st
#151
:
5th
#152
:
18th
#154
:
10th
#155
:
1st
#156
:
1st
#158
:
11th
#159
:
12th
#160
:
1st
#162
:
19th
#163
:
1st
#165
:
2nd
#171
:
1st
#175
:
23rd
#177
:
4th
#178
:
7th
#179
:
4th
#180
:
17th
#181
:
1st
#182
:
7th
#185
:
4th
#187
:
1st
#188
:
21st
#189
:
1st
#190
:
6th
#191
:
3rd
#192
:
8th
#193
:
2nd
#195
:
3rd
#196
:
5th
#197
:
7th
#198
:
11th
#199
:
3rd
#201
:
2nd
#203
:
1st
#204
:
11th
#205
:
10th
#207
:
18th
#211
:
6th
#212
:
5th
#213
:
3rd
#215
:
7th
#216
:
1st
#221
:
8th
#233
:
3rd
#240
:
19th
#242
:
6th
#251
:
12th
#252
:
4th
#253
:
6th
#254
:
6th
#255
:
12th
#257
:
26th
#261
:
12th
#265
:
11th
#266
:
3rd
#269
:
10th
#275
:
23rd
#281
:
4th
#288
:
1st
#290
:
1st
Avg rank:
7th
Entry
Navigation
First
Prev
Entry
7
of
33
Next
Last
Comments? Suggestions? Problems? Click here!
Disclaimer