Welcome to Panachallenge!
If you are already a member, Click Here to Log In.

 
     
t t rss cal
    Home   ·   Rules   ·   Mugshots   ·   Challenges   ·   Stats   ·   Forums   ·   Help Register    

  #99 Ugly
Entry 2 of 14
   
 
Despoiled Waterfronts       ©2011 Jade O.
Panasonic DMC-FZ30       2nd place, 84 points
1/100s, f4.5, ISO 80, 35mm, Normal Program, Pattern, no flash
 
Post-Processing: Three image pano. Crop, resize, sharpen.       Extra Info: Beautiful settings for an ugly assault on nature.

A part of the Toronto waterfront, near the mouth of a once spectacular Don River, a one time natural paradise, has been denuded, and dredged, and shored, and channeled into oblivion. No remanent of what once was, remains, except the water itself. Barren of its former lush temperate forest, mere scrub grasses exist here, and where reeds and waterfoul once nested now lie piles of salt heaped under massive tarps awaiting winter roads, leaching and poisoning the ground and the waters around them. The ugly side of industrialization, the Port of Toronto none the less has helped develop the economic engine of Toronto which now is entering a wondrous post-industrial age, with a "clean" economy which generates revenue to fund the reclamation of wastelands, the rebirth of the urban forest, and the return of wildlife in such projects as the Leslie Street spit -- a natural wonder of nesting bird sanctuaries extending like a finger into Lake Ontario, a fish and migratory bird habitat at the foot of the City core, an untouched wilderness lying just beyond the smokestacks visible here. Given half a chance, nature pushes aside our ugliness to expose her true wonder and beauty, and the marvel of creation.
 
14 comments on this entry
Log in to
add a comment

Franz07
Mar 30, 2011
    Congratulations Jade. Yes, your right - beauty is a key benefit.

Jade O.
Mar 21, 2011
    Very interesting result~! Thanks for all your votes and comments! This prettier photo did better than my Main entry so maybe beauty wins out after all!!!

    Comments After End of Challenge    
    Comments During Voting    

Jade O.
Mar 21, 2011
    Thank you all for your comments. It'll be interesting to see the votes.

This take on ugly seems to have posed the question, not, What is beauty? but rather, What is ugly? It seems ugliness, like beauty, is in the eye of the beholder.

Jade O.
Mar 21, 2011
    Michael, I love these sorts of analyses; yes a split horizon which somehow works though I have no theory why the broken rule is not problem here. I thought the shed essential for depth of field and to add a human perspective to the scene; I tried a clone out of the smokestacks and it looked far too pretty! (see outtakes after the voting is in).
Edited on Mar 21, 2011

Mepo
Mar 21, 2011
    Here's a broken rule (never split the photo with the horizon) that works quite well in this case. I find the shed distracting and I think the photo looks better when it is cropped away. I understand & agree with your description of ugly but once again your skill has turned the scene into something attractive.

Jade O.
Mar 21, 2011
    LaRee, Lo Interesting diversity of opinions; my thought was that ugly scenes can still make beautiful photographs but perhaps I've failed to bring the ugly through since that seems to be a common thread in much of the commentary.

I think for me, water surrounded by industrial development is inherently ugly; smokestacks, powerlines, rusty steel freighters, oversized mounds covered in black tarp and utilitarian industrial buildings, a horrifically ugly intrusion and transformation of what was once a natural paradise rivaling the beauty of any national park.
Edited on Mar 21, 2011

LaRee
Mar 21, 2011
    I just don't get ugly out of this.

Lo
Mar 20, 2011
    It's encouraging to hear that at least in some areas, we are taking responsibility for our assault on nature, and are at least trying to make amends.

Jade O.
Mar 20, 2011
    Thanks, Old Finn!

Old Finn
Mar 20, 2011
    Would be a beautiful picture without those heaps and industrial buildings. So Ugly suits here. My nr 1.

Jade O.
Mar 19, 2011
    raf Ice? Those are giant salt crystals! LOL! (Trust me, for Toronto, this passes as barren AND ugly.)

raf/Franz/rc I considered whether a photo had to be ugly to convey ugliness but decided in my internal debate that it did not. A beautiful image cannot hide an ugly reality and in my mind, beauty could well serve to enhance the ugliness of the reality. Whether I succeeded photographically here, is a whole other matter, however.
Edited on Mar 19, 2011

rafinmelb
Mar 19, 2011
    I am torn here. I like the photo a lot. Is it ugly? Perhaps I am too unfamiliar with icy conditions to consider this truly ugly, even though I understand the things we do to our waterfronts in the interests of industry do despoil otherwise beautiful natural environments.

Franz07
Mar 19, 2011
    Hmm, I've got mixed emotions here. You are showing an ugly place - and the extra info explains it sufficiently, but in the way you took the picture it still has some kind of beauty.
... OK, this sounds stupid - a picture should always look beautiful, even if it shows something wretched.
In my favs.

forkcandles
Mar 18, 2011
    This one is my no1. yes the scene is ugly, there's one near me called avonmouth which has large 2000 plus cars vans on on side motorways over the top and on th left coal depot and a wind farm.
The picture shows both the ugliness but also it beauty.
Entry Navigation
First       Prev       Entry
2 of 14
      Next       Last      

Entry
Navigation



First



Prev


Entry
2 of 14


Next


Last

Vote Stats
12 total votes:

1st  (2): ||
2nd  (2): ||
3rd  (3): |||
4th  (1): |
5th  ():  
6th  (2): ||
7th  (1): |
8th  (0):  
9th  (0):  
10th  (1): |

[Votes]


By Jade O.


Canada

115 Challenge
entries:

#69 63rd
#70 19th
#71 5th
#72 18th
#73 3rd
#74 32nd
#76 11th
#77 10th
#78 15th
#79 4th
#80 7th
#81 19th
#82 12th
#83 5th
#84 7th
#85 8th
#86 10th
#87 14th
#88 6th
#89 6th
#90 7th
#91 8th
#92 8th
#94 11th
#95 13th
#96 13th
#97 6th
#98 5th
#99 13th
#100 10th
#101 1st
#102 4th
#103 18th
#104 1st
#105 4th
#106 17th
#107 18th
#108 6th
#109 10th
#110 10th
#111 9th
#112 7th
#113 5th
#114 4th
#116 6th
#117 28th
#118 13th
#119 1st
#120 9th
#121 2nd
#122 6th
#123 3rd
#124 1st
#125 11th
#126 2nd
#127 4th
#133 1st
#134 2nd
#135 2nd
#136 2nd
#137 15th
#138 3rd
#139 2nd
#140 5th
#141 20th
#142 1st
#143 3rd
#144 10th
#145 4th
#146 4th
#147 33rd
#149 39th
#150 4th
#151 1st
#153 5th
#154 7th
#155 12th
#156 15th
#158 1st
#159 15th
#160 3rd
#161 17th
#163 11th
#165 7th
#166 6th
#167 6th
#168 19th
#169 13th
#170 1st
#171 38th
#172 8th
#173 18th
#174 20th
#180 23rd
#181 11th
#182 10th
#184 28th
#185 31st
#188 22nd
#191 10th
#193 3rd
#195 5th
#196 20th
#197 5th
#200 10th
#202 7th
#210 14th
#254 3rd
#261 17th
#275 20th
#276 3rd
#277 1st
#280 11th
#281 5th
#282 6th

Avg rank:
10th




Entry
Navigation



First



Prev


Entry
2 of 14


Next


Last
    Comments? Suggestions? Problems? Click here!       Disclaimer