Welcome to Panachallenge!
If you are already a member, Click Here to Log In.

t t rss cal
    Home   ·   Rules   ·   Mugshots   ·   Challenges   ·   Stats   ·   Forums   ·   Help Register    

  #124 Monochrome (Gray Scale or Toned)
Entry 2 of 33
Whiteout       ©2013 Mepo
Panasonic DMC-FZ30       2nd place, 243 points
1/80s, f5.6, ISO 80, ?, Aperture Priority, Spot, no flash
Post-Processing: Raw - B&W - Used a gold/blue filter to bring out the detail in the trees. Increased contrast & levels. Cropped to panorama.       Extra Info: Without the trees I would not know where the road is. After viewing the image I realized that the camera had been able see better in the storm that I could.
25 comments on this entry
Log in to
add a comment

May 7, 2013
    oh WOW, sensational, and dreamy, well done!

Mar 12, 2013
    Congratulations - love the idea of Xmas cards or a huge wall hanging - it's definitely a keeper

Mar 12, 2013
    Thanks everyone for the votes and especially the comments. It almost makes that wet snow down my neck worthwhile :-)

While taking this I was threatened by a rent-a-cop security guard with a parking ticket. He claimed I was blocking traffic and wanted me to move to a parking lot a couple of Km away. After I calmed him down a bit I had to push his car to help him get moving again - I was SO tempted to leave him there and report him for blocking the road LOL
Edited on Mar 12, 2013

Mar 12, 2013

Mar 11, 2013
    A well deserved 2nd place. Revisiting my votes I think that I should have placed your image much higher. Would look really nice on the wall.

Mar 11, 2013
    Congratulations. This is a beautiful image that I'd love to have hanging on my wall. It really is gorgeous.

Jade O.
Mar 11, 2013
    Nice perspective. You put the "P" where it mattered most and turned wipeout into whiteout! Congrats on a really strong 2nd place finish.

Mar 11, 2013
    Congrats Michael! Perhaps you can retake this one later for the Pathways challenge!

    Comments After End of Challenge    
    Comments During Voting    

Mar 11, 2013
    Beautifully shot minimal and graphic. A fav. Good luck.
Edited on Mar 11, 2013

Steven Sobel
Mar 11, 2013
    By far my favorite of the landscape images in the main challenge, the blowing snow is epic and the composition is extremely solid. The only little things I could nit-pick are that I'd like to see a little more detail in the tracks on the road and maybe a tiny bit more space around the frame on the sides. Also could clone out the road sign on the left side and a few of the more distracting branches. Very high in my favorites!

Mar 11, 2013
    A quick thank you for all your interesting comments, so many of which addressed parts of the process that gave me some difficulty in deciding which way to go:

Re symmetrical - I did have other shots that were more symmetrical but I prefer a more natural look and I felt the smaller tree added a sense of depth. I must admit however that when I set out to capture this I did have a more symmetrical shot in mind.

Re overexposure: I did over expose on purpose. In my minds eye I wanted a complete white background to demonstrate what you actually are faced with when you are out in a storm like this. When the wind blows the snow into your face you actually see a lot less that the camera captures. On top of which you start to experience snow blindness fairly quickly. The Eskimo use glasses made of bone with a thin slit in them - they work very well.

Re burning in the left tree: Again, I kept it lighter than the right to emphasize the difference in distance.

Re: Detail on road and on the side. I was trying to reduce this to nil but your comments made me realize that it was better to have some left in. Thanks! By the way - there are ditches on both sides of the road so you try to drive right down the middle.

Re fading trees: It was difficult to adjust the levels to the brightness I wanted and still keep some detail in the distance. I was tempted just to let it go (especially as it was not visible with the naked eye) but now I'm glad I left it in.

Re Shutter speed: That was a really hard one. Every time I experimented with a different shutter speed I got a different result. The problem is that the wind, the snow flake size and the intensity of the storm kept changing. I would have preferred to see more actual flakes like I captured in my open entry - but who knows if it would have been better ?

As a matter of interest. When I was trying for the 'right' crop I remembered the recent discussion of Fibonacci and the Golden Rectangle. I tried it and it looked just right. I highly recommend it as a cropping guide.

Thanks again for every comment. They are invaluable.
Edited on Mar 11, 2013

Old Finn
Mar 10, 2013
    Excellent.. The surface of the road and the snow walls is enough visible and the dark trees make the graphic impression of the picture.

Mar 9, 2013
    Very nice image. Love the trees fading into the background.

Mar 9, 2013
    "simple" composition black and white and yet so effective. In my TT.

Steven T
Mar 8, 2013
    Well done. One of my favorites in the challenge. Good work to keep a hint of detail in the roadway. Perfect shutter speed to blur the snow. Looks as cold and bleak as a Canadian winter.

Mar 8, 2013
    This would make a very good mood picture

Mar 8, 2013
    Beautifully balanced - love the starkness of the trees against the white background

Mar 8, 2013
    Thank you all for the great comments. I'm blown away (as I nearly was in the storm :-) My intention in adjusting the contrast and levels was to try and reproduce the blinding effect of the storm.

Mar 8, 2013
    First Impression - 5/5
Contrast - 5/5
Composition - 5/5
Tone / Texture - 5/5

Brilliant image. Maybe helped by slightly burning in the first tree on the left hand side.

Mar 8, 2013
    Great photo, looks like these trees a re lined up in the middle of nowhere. Think your a little over exposed though.

Mar 8, 2013
    I love the high key snowy atmosphere, courageous shot, very nicely composed - well done!

Jade O.
Mar 7, 2013
    This one will grow on me. You've made a classic high key presentation without forcing it artificially. If the trees were perfectly symmetrical (feat of nature not photographer) this would rank even higher for me.

Mar 7, 2013
    This just works on every level and I have no doubt it'll do extremely well in voting notwithstanding making one heck of a gorgeous print or canvas (HUGE size) that would simply make a superb focal point on any living room wall. It's way up in my T5 list. Love it!

Mar 7, 2013
    i have this in second place at the moment. i feel there may only be two in the main that excel and would print well and have a life outside our challenge. (use this for you own holiday greetings card next year) it is beautiful.

Mar 7, 2013
    Love love love this. Oh my it does look cold. What a majestic scene to my eye. I think this is my favorite in the main.
Entry Navigation
First       Prev       Entry
2 of 33
      Next       Last      




2 of 33



Vote Stats
34 total votes:

1st  (5): |||||
2nd  (8): ||||||||
3rd  (4): ||||
4th  (9): |||||||||
5th  ():  
6th  (4): ||||
7th  (0):  
8th  (0):  
9th  (2): ||
10th  (2): ||


By Mepo


154 Challenge

#69 43rd
#71 9th
#74 18th
#75 20th
#76 10th
#77 5th
#79 4th
#80 1st
#82 8th
#83 2nd
#84 12th
#85 5th
#86 4th
#87 6th
#88 9th
#89 12th
#90 11th
#91 8th
#92 7th
#93 14th
#94 18th
#95 18th
#96 12th
#97 1st
#98 9th
#99 9th
#100 1st
#101 7th
#102 5th
#103 2nd
#104 9th
#105 7th
#106 5th
#107 10th
#108 20th
#109 23rd
#110 6th
#111 6th
#112 21st
#113 5th
#114 6th
#115 13th
#116 9th
#117 12th
#118 3rd
#119 12th
#120 5th
#121 13th
#122 7th
#123 11th
#124 5th
#125 4th
#126 3rd
#127 7th
#128 8th
#129 6th
#130 5th
#131 10th
#133 3rd
#134 12th
#135 6th
#136 7th
#137 9th
#138 6th
#139 1st
#140 14th
#141 21st
#142 1st
#143 2nd
#144 1st
#145 16th
#146 2nd
#147 15th
#148 4th
#149 2nd
#150 5th
#151 8th
#152 23rd
#153 7th
#154 4th
#155 10th
#156 14th
#157 14th
#158 17th
#159 11th
#160 1st
#161 11th
#162 15th
#164 17th
#165 5th
#166 4th
#167 14th
#168 16th
#169 17th
#171 29th
#172 23rd
#173 8th
#174 10th
#175 16th
#176 9th
#177 7th
#178 5th
#179 6th
#180 12th
#181 3rd
#182 22nd
#183 4th
#184 7th
#185 5th
#186 7th
#187 7th
#188 1st
#189 3rd
#190 12th
#191 4th
#192 23rd
#193 22nd
#194 1st
#195 21st
#196 6th
#197 11th
#198 15th
#199 15th
#200 20th
#201 15th
#202 16th
#203 5th
#204 18th
#205 1st
#206 14th
#207 13th
#208 7th
#209 18th
#210 16th
#211 5th
#212 7th
#213 6th
#214 13th
#215 13th
#216 14th
#217 11th
#218 10th
#219 3rd
#220 13th
#221 15th
#222 15th
#223 8th
#224 12th
#225 25th
#226 22nd
#227 1st
#229 2nd
#230 3rd
#231 7th

Avg rank:




2 of 33


    Comments? Suggestions? Problems? Click here!       Disclaimer